A Resource from the Episcopal Diocese of Dallas

 

http://www.missionalchurchnet.org

 

This Month’s

Recommended Books

Comeback Churches

By Ed Stetzer and Mike Dodson

 

 

Ancient Wisdom

Mark gets a pink slip. . .

Some time later Paul said to Barnabas, "Let us go back and visit the brothers in all the towns where we preached the word of the Lord and see how they are doing." Barnabas wanted to take John, also called Mark, with them, but Paul did not think it wise to take him, because he had deserted them in Pamphylia and had not continued with them in the work. They had such a sharp disagreement that they parted company.

—Acts 15:37-39

The rest of the story  . . .

Get Mark and bring him with you, because he is helpful to me in my ministry.

2 Timothy 4:11

God’s plan . . .

Although there appears to be a sharp contention [between Barnabas and Paul], in fact it was part of the divine plan that each man should receive his proper place.

John Chrysostom

What is needed . . .

There is need not of pomp of words but of strong minds, of skill in the Scriptures and of powerful thoughts.

John Chrysostom

Reproof and respect . . .

The Country Parson . . . procures [respect] . . . by a bold and impartial reproof, even of the best in the Parish, when occasion requires: for this may produce hatred in those that are reproved, but never contempt either in them, or others.

 George Herbert

A balancing act  . . .

Courage, conviction, and long-range vision must be balanced by tact and patience and humor. Prayer and wise counsel will help him to distinguish between his own wishes and God’s will, and between what is presently urgent and what can wait.

 Sam Shoemaker

 

Lighten Up

How Many Lawyers

There is a finite number of physicians that a population of fixed size will support. The same theory holds for teachers and engineers. However, this principle does not seem to apply to lawyers. The more you have, the more you need.

 

For Missional Leaders in the Episcopal Diocese of Dallas and  Beyond

 

July 15, 2007

 

 

How to Terminate an Employee

Canon Neal Michell

 

I know this is an unpleasant subject. I have served as the interim rector for a church for the last seven months. One of my first duties as interim rector was to terminate an employee. I took no pleasure in it, but it had to be done. No one likes firing someone, whether it is for misconduct, or a wrong fit, or because the church simply can’t afford that position any more. But, if you have to do it, you need to do it right.

John Maxwell has said that who you don’t fire is more important than who you hire. Keeping the wrong staff member can do untold damage to your church. We don’t like to do it, but at some point you will have to.  Here is what I’ve learned over the years about employees.

1. First, read your employee manual. Don’t have an employee manual? Oops. Your church ought to have an employee manual. If you don’t, get started on it tomorrow. 

An employee manual, if properly drafted, will guide you through the process of disciplining and terminating the employee. It gives both the employee as well as the church notice as to what the obligations are.

2. Next, read the letter of agreement by which the employee was hired.  It may provide some guidance as well. Is the employee still on probation? (You do hire people with a probationary period, don’t you?) Again, both the employee and the church will be bound by the letter of agreement.

3.  Call you diocesan office and ask to speak to one of the diocesan chancellors who deals with labor law.  Many dioceses have such a person who can guide you through the process and avoid mistakes and pitfalls which might bring unnecessary liability upon the church.

In addition, The Church Pension Group has a helpful book Human Resources Practices for Lay Employees of the Episcopal Church, that is quite helpful. It has a full chapter on terminations.

4.  Don’t confuse your pastoral role with your managerial role. Don’t avoid the real reason that the person is being released because you want to be nice to the person. It is tempting to want to be pastoral in your relationship with the employee and not give the real reason the employee is being terminated. Sometimes a fired employee will file a complaint. If the reasons for termination are not clear, you may open the church and yourself up to a lawsuit. Further, not being honest about the reasons for termination does not help that employee to grow as a person.

5.  Don’t surprise the employee with the reasons for termination at the termination meeting. If you are terminating the employee for cause or underperformance of some sort, the employee’s file should have had some written document acknowledging the misconduct. Also, in case of misconduct, the document should be signed by the employee and placed in the file. In case of underperformance, a performance review or memo acknowledging the underperformance should be placed in the employee’s file.

6.  If being terminated for misconduct, don’t let the employee remain on the job. Have the employee clean out the desk immediately. You may want to give some sort of severance, but don’t have the employee remain on the job just because he or she is being paid. Let the employee get on with life. Do not write a reference letter at this time.  Later, if and when a letter of reference is requested, provide only dates of employment. Consult your diocesan or church chancellor as to what exactly you can say in a reference letter.

7.  Sometimes an employee is simply not a good fit. There is no misconduct, per se, just a bad fit or you have an employee who does not ‘buy into’ the vision that has been established. With this employee, try framing the termination in terms of that person’s individual growth and development and what God might be doing in that person’s life. This is where you can exercise your pastoral relationship. Don’t confuse the two.

8.  Don’t have a termination meeting with the employee alone.  Have your Senior Warden or the Administrator present with you as a witness to what was said and what was not said. 

9.  Pray before you do anything else. It may be that God has also been speaking to your employee things not working out for that person with the church. If God has been nudging you with dissatisfaction over this employee’s performance, it is quite likely that your employee is hearing the same thing.

By the way, this does not apply only to paid employees. You might consider terminating an underperforming volunteer. You might be doing them a favor.

 

Until next time,

 

Neal+

 

P.S. I know that my newsletters have been infrequent lately. I’ve been serving as interim rector of a church along with my full-time duties on the staff of the Diocese of Dallas.

 

 


Unsubscribe     Update Email Address       For Previous Newsletters Go Here

 

Copyright © 2007 Neal O. Michell, all rights reserved

We believe in the Power of Jesus Christ to Transform lives.  We are Resurrection People!